Anyone else try convincing themselves that Arctic Zero was actually good back in the day? Yeah… same. Thankfully, the Ninja Creami has changed the game - turning protein shakes into thick, creamy ice cream that actually satisfies those dessert cravings.
Here’s the high-protein recipe I’ve been loving lately. It feels indulgent but still keeps me on track!
Why You’ll Love It
Dessert-like flavor and texture with a nutrition boost
Over 25g of protein (depending on your powder)
Endless mix-in options so you can make it your own
A guilt-free way to enjoy ice cream any night of the week
Ingredients (Serves 1)
Base:
1 cup unsweetened almond milk
1 cup Fairlife 2% milk
1 scoop protein powder (I used Dymatize Fruity Pebbles flavor)
1 serving sugar-free vanilla Jell-O pudding mix
Dash of vanilla extract
¼ tsp xanthan gum (don’t skip this - it’s the secret to a thick, creamy texture)
Mix-ins/Toppings (optional):
Cereal (I used Froot Loops)
Marshmallow fluff
Cool Whip
Instructions
Make the base: Combine all base ingredients in a blender until smooth. Pour into your Creami container.
Freeze: Place in the freezer for at least 24 hours.
Spin: When ready to enjoy, let the container sit at room temp for 10 minutes, then run under hot water for 15–30 seconds.
Process: Insert into the Ninja Creami and spin. If powdery, scrape the sides, add a splash of almond milk, and re-spin as needed.
Add mix-ins: Stir in cereal, marshmallow fluff, or any toppings you love.
Serve and enjoy!
Pro Tips for the Perfect Creami
Always prep your base 24 hours in advance (shorter times = milkshake texture).
Let the container warm up slightly before spinning for best results.
Scrape the sides after the first spin to avoid icy bits.
Don’t be afraid to re-spin multiple times, it only gets creamier!
Flavor Ideas
Switch up the protein powder and mix-ins for endless variations:
Cookies & Cream: Vanilla or cookies and cream protein powder base + crushed Oreo Thins or Minis + fluff as a mix-in or topping
Chocolate Peanut Butter Swirl: Chocolate or PB protein powder + Reese’s thins as a mix-in + PB drizzle for topping
Cake Batter: Cake batter protein powder + top/mix-in frosted animal crackers
Nutrition Highlights
This Ninja Creami creation is:
High in protein (25-30g+ depending on your protein powder)
Lower in calories than traditional ice cream
Customizable with endless flavor and topping combos
A creamy, indulgent treat that fits into your nutrition goals
Say goodbye to sad diet ice creams - this Ninja Creami protein ice cream is the real deal. Which flavor combo are you trying first?
